What is it? Why is it important?

An audit is a systematic evaluation of study related activities including the review of essential documents, with the aim to assess study compliance with the study protocol, study SOPs, ICH GCP, EC, including applicable regulatory requirements (e.g. Swissmedic, FOPH).

 

Audits are generally conducted to assess compliance with Quality Assurance (QA) processes established by the SP-INV of the study. Under special circumstances “for-cause” audits are implemented following the identification of critical issue(s) during monitoring, or the suspicion of non-compliance.

 

The SP-INV carries main study responsibility, which includes the implementation of a risk-based QMS.

 

As an integral part of QA activities, audits are conducted independently and separately from routine monitoring or other quality control functions. In contrast to an evaluation of study risks and monitoring activities, audits are not considered mandatory.

More

An audit is initiated by the SP-INV of a study, and is based on the following standardised activities.

 

Audit preparation, the SP-INV:

  • Defines the audit scope, frequency, methodology (e.g. on-site or central), sites to be audited, including format and content of the audit report
  • Notifies the participating study site (e.g. Site-INV) of the upcoming audit, and requests relevant study documents for review
  • Forwards the audit agenda to the Site-INV

 

Audit conduct:

  • Opening meeting. The audit team (e.g. defined by the SP-INV) informs about the aim and scope of the audit
  • Auditors perform the audit (e.g. review processes and related documents, interview study staff on tasks and responsibilities)
  • Closing meeting. Auditors summarise audit findings and address any remaining questions

 

Audit follow-up:

  • Auditors prepare an audit report summarising findings and distributes it to the SP-INV and Site-INV
  • Based on the audit report, the Site-INV provides auditors with a CAPA plan
  • The CAPA plan is submitted to the SP-INV who approves the plan on how to correct and prevent findings. The plan includes a timeline needed for the resolution of finings with a reference to staff responsible for handling the findings

 

An audit can target specific aspects of a study, as well as its partners and service providers (e.g. laboratories, manufacturers, outsourced monitoring services, CROs).

What do I need to do?

As a SP-INV and according to your Quality Assurance strategy:

  • Define the scope, frequency, methodology, and partakers involved in the audit process (i.e. who-, what-, when- and how to audit)
  • Use a risk based approach when planning the audit, focusing on the most critical study aspects (e.g. participant safety, data quality)
  • Select auditors that are independent of the study or system to be audited
  • Ensure auditors are qualified by training and experience 

 

When planning the audit scope, and apart from a primary risk-based focus, you may also consider the complexity of the study, and the number of study participants. 

More

  • Any findings observed during an audit are documented in an audit report
  • Findings are categorised according to level of risk to study participants and quality of study data (e.g. minor, major, and critical findings, according to EMA's grading of inspection findings)
  • The auditee provides the SP-INV and auditors with a CAPA plan, where corrective and preventative actions are defined
  • CAPA resolutions are given specific timelines, with high-risk findings requiring immediate action on the part of the study site
  • Upon the successful completion of an audit, auditors can issue an audit certificate that is forwarded to the Site-INV to be filed in the ISF

 

The auditee or Site-INV responsible for a specific study site, must implement any corrective measures as defined in the CAPA plan. Thus, applicable control measures should be in place to ensure CAPA compliance, and the prevetion of future issues.

Where can I get help?

Your local Research Support Centre can assist you with experienced staff regarding this topic

  • Basel, Departement Klinische Forschung (DKF), dkf.unibas.ch

  • Lugano, Clinical Trials Unit (CTU-EOC), ctueoc.ch

  • Bern, Department of Clinical Research (DCR), dcr.unibe.ch

  • Geneva, Clinical Research Center (CRC), crc.hug.ch

  • Lausanne, Clinical Research Center (CRC), chuv.ch

  • St. Gallen, Clinical Trials Unit (CTU), h-och.ch

  • Zürich, Clinical Trials Center (CTC), usz.ch

References

ICH GCP E6(R2) – see in particular guidelines

  • 1.6 Audit definition
  • 5.18 Study monitoring
  • 5.19 Audit

ISO 9001:2015 (access liable to costs) – see in particular section

  • Quality Management Systems
Abbreviations
  • CAPA – Corrective and Preventative Action
  • CRO – Contract Research Organisation
  • CTU – Clinical Trials Unit
  • EC – Ethics Committee
  • FOPH – Federal Office of Public Health
  • ICH GCP – International Council for Harmonisation Good Clinical Practice
  • ISF – Investigator Site File
  • ISO – International Organization for Standardization
  • QA – Quality Assurance
  • QMS – Quality Management System
  • SOP – Standard Operating Procedures
  • Site-INV – Site-Investigator
  • SP-INV – Sponsor-Investigator
Development ↦ Quality and Risk ↦ Quality Assurance ↦ Audit
Study
Basic

Provides some background knowledge and basic definitions

Basic Monitoring
Concept

Starts with a study idea

Ends after having assessed and evaluated study feasibility

Concept Statistic Methodology
Concept Drug or Device
Development

Starts with confidence that the study is feasible

Ends after having received ethics and regulatory approval

Development Drug or Device
Set-Up

Starts with ethics and regulatory approval

Ends after successful study initiation

Set-Up Ethics and Laws
Set-Up Statistic Methodology
Set-Up Quality and Risk
Set-Up Drug or Device
Conduct

Starts with participant recruitment

Ends after the last participant has completed the last study visit

Conduct Statistic Methodology
Conduct Drug or Device
Completion

Starts with last study visit completed

Ends after study publication and archiving

Completion Drug or Device
Current Path (click to copy): Development ↦ Quality and Risk ↦ Quality Assurance ↦ Audit

Please note: the Easy-GCS tool is currently under construction.